Two cases for and against capital punishment

Many people believe that retribution is morally flawed and problematic in concept and practice.

Two cases for and against capital punishment

The Conservative Case Against Capital Punishment The death penalty process is too wasteful and expensive to justify any longer.

Last monthNebraska became the first red state to repeal capital punishment in over 40 years. The effort was led by conservatives who oppose the death penalty for a variety of reasons, including its enormous cost. In states that still have capital punishment on the books, it has become a burden on taxpayers because the death penalty process, like so many other government programs, is wasteful and inefficient.

The decision to seek a death sentence is settled very early in the process by the prosecution, and that decision can have major fiscal ramifications, which have led to budget crises and tax increases.

The pre-trial and trial segments are the most costly portions of the process because capital trials involve more time, more motions and deeper investigations, and they require more attorneys, court employees and expert witnesses. In Colorado, for example, studies have estimated that death penalty trials are six times longer than similar non-death cases.

In Kansas, defense costs were found to be four times higher in capital-punishment proceedings. Supreme Court Rejects Death Penalty Challenge The costs of capital cases bear heavily on local governments and their taxpayers as well.

Jasper County, Texas, raised its property taxes by 6. One reason capital cases are so costly is that they involve not one but two trials. After the guilt-or-innocence phase of a death penalty case has been concluded, there is another trial to decide whether the offender should be sentenced to death.

This sentencing trial is unique to capital cases and adds many more days to the total trial time, necessitating more hours from judges, attorneys and jurors. And once those trials are completed, the much-criticized appeals process begins.

There are three levels of appeals in capital cases, whereas there is only one in non-death proceedings. The death penalty appeals process can take decades. Sixty-eight percent of death sentences are overturned on appeal, requiring much of the expensive process to begin again.

But appeals serve an important purpose: They are the reason that many people sentenced to die have been released after being wrongly convicted.

And then there are the much higher incarceration costs associated with capital punishment. Housing inmates on death row is far more expensive than keeping them in the general population of a medium- or maximum-security prison.

When death-row inmates are put to death, as about 10 percent ultimately are, the execution inflicts additional costs on the state. These high costs are driven, in part, by government mandates and the desire to avoid executing an innocent person.

Two cases for and against capital punishment

In an era when fiscal mismanagement and wasteful government programs are the status quo, capital punishment is a prime example of financial irresponsibility.The Conservative Case Against the Death Penalty capital punishment cases can be two to three times more expensive than comparable cases in which the death penalty is not sought.

Jun 01,  · Without capital punishment, it could be argued that the justice system makes no provision in response to the crime of murder, and thus provides no justice for the victim. FlameHorse is an absolute pacifist who loves animals, but eats burgers.

the. Death. of the. Death Penalty. Why the era of capital punishment is ending. By David Von Drehle. The case of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev absorbed Americans as no death-penalty drama has in years.

Summaries of Key Supreme Court Cases Related to the Death Penalty. Witherspoon v. Illinois, U.S. (): Jurors must be willing to impose the death penalty in order to sit on a capital jury.

Summaries of Key Supreme Court Cases Related to the Death Penalty. Witherspoon v. Illinois, U.S. (): Jurors must be willing to impose the death penalty in order to sit on a capital jury. The Connecticut Supreme Court has confronted questions that legal cases seldom answer: Is capital punishment moral?

A Strong Argument Against Capital Punishment. Two of the death-row.

List of United States Supreme Court decisions on capital punishment - Wikipedia